Nancy’s main experience thus far has been as in-house General Counsel, which started a year after graduating law school. She handled everything from contract negotiations, and compliance (including ITAR, Blood borne Pathogen Programs, Dangerous Goods, OSHA Safety, and Data and Privacy) to general business matters. Nancy’s experience has given her an in depth understanding of client needs when approaching problems, because she is used to sitting in their shoes when being the problem solver.

Graduating with her Bachelor’s Degree a year early, Nancy took a year off prior to starting law school. During that time she worked for a local non-profit organization, The Woman’s City Club, managing their office, and for a local practitioner running her traffic division as her paralegal.  As if she wasn’t busy enough, she’d spend nights serving at a local restaurant.

In law school, Nancy was a member of the Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot Team, helped out with the U.S Sixth Circuit Appellate Clinic, and was a teaching assistant for the Dean.

Nancy loves to travel and spent a month backpacking across Europe with her sister, and even met the Pope while on her honeymoon in Italy. She lives in Milford with her husband, their daughter Eleanor, and their two dogs Jeffry & Thor.


University of Cincinnati, B.S., Criminal Justice, cum laude, 2014

University of Cincinnati College of Law, J.D., 2018

Professional Activities

Cincinnati Bar Association

International Association of Privacy Professionals (IAPP) - Member

Kappa Delta Alumni Association-Omega Xi Chapter - Advisor


Presentations & Publications

Outside The Office

Nancy Magoteaux was fourteen years old when she sat next to her sister in the bed of a pickup truck, laughing hysterically as it raced through an open field. Their feet were dangling over the edge of the open tailgate as their mother pushed down on the gas. A fifty-foot rope tethered the back of the truck to an ultralight, which is basically a go-cart with wings. In the pilot’s seat of the ultralight, being dragged behind them, was their father, bouncing up and down, hoping to fly.

Nancy’s father purchased the half-buggy half-aircraft during one of his midlife crises, according to Nancy. It didn’t have an engine, but that didn’t stop him from seeing if he could still get it off the ground.

Everyone had their doubts. The ride, at that point, was nothing more than a spectacle as they watched him struggle to keep control atop the uneven terrain. Another dad stunt, they thought, that quite literally wouldn’t get off the ground. But then, the right bump at just the right moment gave him enough air to go up and stay up. Nancy said the rope let him get up to about thirty feet as he flew behind them like a kite on the end of a string.

“We were all dying laughing. He’s just flying around behind this pickup in a field, and he’s holding on for dear life. You can tell from the look on his face that he was more surprised than anyone that it actually worked.”

Now we all know that apples don’t fall too far from the tree. Even though Nancy’s sense of adventure is a little more subdued, she still has her moments. During college, she and her sister took off for about a month to backpack in Europe. They started in Greece, then wandered through Austria, Switzerland, Germany, eventually ending in Ireland. The questionable hotels made the trip quite eventful, especially that one that required them to barricade their doors because there were no locks. And of course, they’ll never forget climbing the wrong tower in Switzerland only to see the tower they actually wanted to climb 1,000 mistaken steps later.

More recently, Nancy happened to be in Pompeii with her husband when she learned that she passed the Bar Exam. The joke was that she would either be jumping into the volcano or running down it to celebrate with wine after she got the news. They chose a bottle of Prosecco, but to this day, Nancy insists that things could have ended up differently had she not run through the streets of Rome at 4am the day before to shake the Pope’s hand.

It’s interesting to think about how this sense of adventure developed in a girl from Waynesburg, Ohio, a one traffic light village southeast of Akron. It used to have a grocery store before it went out of business, making a McDonald’s the town’s main attraction. You’re probably thinking she wanted to escape, but Nancy has nothing but great things to say about the place where she grew up and the influence it had on her.

Nancy, like her parents, is definitely a DIYer. She learned to sew in 4-H, and years of hanging around her father taught her to build things and solve all the problems that arise in the process. The outdoor kitchen at her home was designed and built by Nancy, and so was their custom kitchen island. If Nancy wants new curtains or needs a Halloween costume for their daughter, she just makes them herself.

These do-it-yourself skills always led Nancy to think that she’d be an engineer of some sort. In fact, the no-brainer path in life was for Nancy to become an engineer, then go work for her father’s excavation business, but Nancy wanted a bigger challenge. After watching her parents build a thriving business from the ground up, it inspired Nancy to do the same thing, but in her own way. It’s one of the reasons she moved to Cincinnati; to start from scratch and build a career out of nothing — the ultimate DIY project.

It was Nancy’s aunt, a lawyer out of Akron, and her fancy shoes that inspired Nancy to choose law. Nancy’s attraction to opulence growing up earned her the name Fancy Nancy long before the popular children’s book was written. Anything that shined, sparkled, or otherwise blinged, always got Nancy’s attention, and so when she would visit her aunt and see those sleek business suits and high heels, it inspired a more cosmopolitan path in life for Nancy; one of big cities and big business, and of course, her own pair of fancy shoes.

Today, Nancy makes the trip up north to visit family about once a month. Her father graduated from flying go-carts to flying helicopters. He actually acquired an old LAPD helicopter equipped with a PA system, and his latest hobby is to fly around Waynesburg telling people to come out of their homes with their hands up. It’s enough to make Nancy laugh, and wonder if she should have gotten into criminal law at the same time.

Nancy Magoteaux, Bricker Graydon LLP Photo

Nancy S. Magoteaux

  • 312 Walnut Street
    Suite 1800
    Cincinnati, OH 45202 -4152


  • State of Ohio
Jump to Page

Necessary Cookies

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may disable these by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Analytical Cookies

Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.